Effective Monday December 14, 2020, our offices will be closed to the public until further notice due to the on-going pandemic. However we are working in the office to service your policies. Our offices have secure drop boxes outside each office that can be used to submit paperwork, payments, etc. Our website contains information to make payments or report claims directly to our companies if that is more convenient. If you have questions or concerns, please contact us. We wish everyone a Blessed Christmas and a Happy & Healthy New Year!
Online Payment is available in the following companies:
Would you rather pay by phone?
The following numbers are available to call to pay directly by phone. Please be aware that other fees may apply when paying by phone.
Auto Owners Insurance Company: (800) 288-8740
Cincinnati Insurance Companies: (800) 364-3400
Goodville Mutual Insurance Company: (800) 448-4622
Grange Insurance Company: (800) 425-1100
Libetry Mutual Insurance Company: (866) 290-2920
Mennonite Mutual Insurance Company: (800) 678-6885
Ohio Fair Plan: (800) 282-1772
Progressive: (800) 876-5581
Safeco Insurance Company: (866) 472-3326
Westfield Insurance Company: (800) 552-9134